Bradley J. Birzer foreign policy

I should really be preparing three lectures on the liberal arts and Christian Humanism I’m giving this weekend, but I became so infuriated by this article (well, what it describes) that I had to take a short break from lecture prep and vent. Not that I think The Imaginative Conservative should be used for personal venting.

Well, not normally, anyway.

Has any other reader of The Imaginative Conservative read the opening to this story in the Washington Post yet:

A group of 37 former administration officials, academics and foreign policy figures on Monday sent a letter to House Republicans urging them not to support any legislation aimed at defunding the U.S. military mission in Libya. The letter, which was circulated by the Foreign Policy Institute, a conservative think tank, comes as the House is poised to consider a defense appropriations bill that may serve as a vehicle for amendments on the Libyan conflict. House Speaker John Boehner (R-Ohio) said on Friday that President Obama has not sufficiently answered lawmakers’ questions on the U.S. military operation and that the House may move to defund it as soon as this week. Most of the signatories of the letter are conservative-leaning foreign policy hawks, including former deputy assistant secretary of state Liz Cheney; former deputy secretary of defense Paul Wolfowitz; Weekly Standard editor Bill Kristol; former Bush administration senior adviser Karl Rove; and Randy Scheunemann, a former foreign policy advisor to Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.)

What does “Conservative-leaning foreign policy hawks” mean? Really?

Now, as most of you know, I’m not always big on labels. I’m happy to be called a “conservative” or a “libertarian” or an “individualist” or a “non-front porch republican,” though I generally self-identify, perhaps somewhat pretentiously, as a “Christian Humanist” or “Augustinian Reaganite.”

I do know a few things for certain. I know I love Jesus, the U.S. Constitution, Human Freedom, and the Liberal Arts.

Frankly, such labels are merely another means by which a sloppy society and a sloppy way of thinking attempt to conform us, to make us less than men and women.

Happily, I’m a man of the Right, a despiser of ideologies and every variety of statism.

But, I do know that real men oppose centralizing power in the hands of one person or one branch of government. And, I never doubt the manhood of a conservative.

So, if 37 “Conservative-leaning foreign policy hawks” want Obama to keep bombing—in a manner immoral and unconstitutional and Truman-esque—the peoples of Libya, I have a very hard time believing them men (and, by default, conservatives).

At least the New Dealers had the guts to call themselves liberals and progressives as they interned fine Americans of Japanese ancestry and nuked their homeland mercilessly.

As I look over the list of 37 signatories, I see a lot of humans claiming the label of conservative without having a clue as to what to conserve. These humans—whether in the Nixon or Bush administrations; or most likely both—look far more like radicals and revolutionaries of the French variety than they do American patriots of order and liberty.

If the American people want war, that’s one thing. If they do, they need to go through their representatives in the House and ask the House to declare war and the Senate to concur.

American society as a whole needs to decide this, after prolonged discussion and recognition of the weighty principles involved.

But, one president abusing his constitutional authority to the point of non-recognition of the constitution does not a legitimate war make, no matter what 37 neo-cons might desire in their warped, inhumane, little progressive hearts.

Books mentioned in this essay may be found in The Imaginative Conservative Bookstore

All comments are moderated and must be civil, concise, and constructive to the conversation. Comments that are critical of an essay may be approved, but comments containing ad hominem criticism of the author will not be published. Also, comments containing web links or block quotations are unlikely to be approved. Keep in mind that essays represent the opinions of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Imaginative Conservative or its editor or publisher.

Leave a Comment
Print Friendly, PDF & Email